Transgender Women Banned from Int’l Swimming Events: They Have a 'Performance Advantage,' Organization Rules

Michael Foust | Contributor | Monday, June 20, 2022
Transgender Women Banned from Int’l Swimming Events: They Have a 'Performance Advantage,' Organization Rules

Transgender Women Banned from Int’l Swimming Events: They Have a 'Performance Advantage,' Organization Rules

Three months after a transgender athlete won an NCAA title, the international organization that oversees swimming competitions on Sunday approved new rules prohibiting biological males from competing in women’s competitions if they have gone through male puberty.

The International Swimming Federation, known worldwide as FINA, approved the new policy with 71.5 percent of the vote. It will prohibit swimmers such as Penn’s Lia Thomas from competing in international competitions – including the Olympics – and from being eligible for world records. Thomas, in March, became the first transgender woman to win an NCAA championship with a dominant performance in the women’s 500-yard freestyle. Thomas previously swam for Penn as a man.

The new FINA rules prohibit transgender athletes from swimming in women’s competitions if they transitioned after the age of 12. FINA says it will work toward establishing an “open” category for swimmers who are transgender women.

Male to female transgender athletes may only compete in FINA meets if they “can establish they have not experienced any part of male puberty,” said FINA Executive Director Brent Nowicki.

FINA cited studies showing that males have a “relative performance advantage over biological females.”

“A biological female athlete cannot overcome that advantage through training or nutrition,” FINA said.

Michael Joyner of the Mayo Clinic said male-to-female transgender athletes maintain their advantage even after taking hormone suppressors.

“Testosterone in male puberty alter the physiological determinants of human performance and explain the sex-based differences in human performance that are clearly evident by age 12,” Joyner said, according to “Even if testosterone is suppressed, its performance-enhancing effects will be retained.”

A paper by researchers from Marquette University, Duke University and the Mayo Clinic found about a 5 percent difference across the board between Thomas’ best times as a female compared to Thomas’ best times competing as a male. By comparison, biological men competing in elite competitions are about 10-15 percent faster than biological women in short events and 7-10 percent faster in long-distance events, the paper found.


Female Swimmer Accuses NCAA of Favoring Trans Athlete Lia Thomas after They Tied at Swim Meet

All-American Swimmer Blasts NCAA Transgender Rules: 'That Final Spot Was Taken from Me'

USA Swimming Changes Rules for Trans Athletes, 'Acknowledges' That Men Have an Advantage

Lia Thomas Wins Women's NCAA Title, 2 Years after Competing as a Man

DeSantis Names 2nd-Place Swimmer 'the Rightful Winner': the NCAA Is 'Complicit in a Lie'

Photo courtesy: ©Getty Images/SolisImages

Michael Foust has covered the intersection of faith and news for 20 years. His stories have appeared in Baptist Press, Christianity Today, The Christian Post, the Leaf-Chroniclethe Toronto Star and the Knoxville News-Sentinel.