CNN Criticized for Redefining Women to 'Individuals with a Cervix' in Medical Story

Michael Foust | Contributor | Wednesday, August 5, 2020
CNN Criticized for Redefining Women to 'Individuals with a Cervix' in Medical Story

CNN Criticized for Redefining Women to 'Individuals with a Cervix' in Medical Story

CNN and other media outlets were panned over the weekend for avoiding the word “women” in reports about new cervical cancer screening guidelines.

The stories focused on new guidelines from the American Cancer Society, which now recommends that women have their first cervical cancer screening at age 25 (instead of 21) with an HPV test instead of a pap test, and that the HPV test be completed every five years through the age of 65.

press release from the American Cancer Society used the term “individuals with a cervix” but also included the word “women” four times, interchangeably.

The CNN online story avoided the word “women” altogether and used phrases such as “individuals with a cervix” and “those with a hysterectomy,” reflecting terminology preferred by LGBT groups.

A story on the website of NBC’s Today Show referenced “people with a cervix” in the first paragraph, although it did use the word “women” several times in the story.

ABC’s story used the word “women” throughout and avoided references to “individuals” or “people.”

Most of the controversy, though, focused on CNN, based partially on a network tweet that went viral.

“‘Individuals with a cervix.’ I'm pretty sure there's a word for these individuals but I can't be certain,” conservative commentator Matt Walsh wrote, sarcastically.

“Dear @CNN, stop reducing us to ‘individuals with a cervix.’ Stop dissociating our identities from our bodies. We are women,” tweeted Katie McCoy, a writer and a professor at Scarborough College of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. “Not composites of our biology. Not abstractions from our biology. Women.”

Sky News host Rita Panahi also criticized CNN.

“In my mind it’s misogynist[ic],” Panahi said. “They can't say women anymore because that apparently would offend some segments of the LGBTQI-plus community. [But] I doubt it would. So now we’re individuals with a cervix.”

Photo courtesy: ©Getty Images/monkeybusinessimages

Michael Foust has covered the intersection of faith and news for 20 years. His stories have appeared in Baptist Press, Christianity Today, The Christian Post, the Leaf-Chroniclethe Toronto Star and the Knoxville News-Sentinel.