The Ignominious Appeasement Award

Cal Thomas | Syndicated columnist | Published: Oct 21, 2002

The Ignominious Appeasement Award

Alfred Nobel must have been a good man, full of good intentions. The science and literature prizes named for him recognize legitimate achievement in these disciplines.


I do not doubt Nobel's sincerity in establishing a"peace prize" to honor people who pursue peace, even though it was born from his guilt at inventing dynamite. Too bad he didn't give us sufficient guidance as to what peace looks and feels like.

The committee now in charge of distributing the money and awarding the medal with Nobel's likeness on it apparently doesn't understand real peace, either. If its members did, they would not have selected the likes of Yasser Arafat, Henry Kissinger and, recently, former President Jimmy Carter, who builds houses much better than he constructs peaceful relations between rival tribes, tongues and nations.


In geopolitical terms, peace on Earth does not come from diplomatic goodwill toward tyrannical men. It usually follows a war in which profound differences are settled on the battlefield, and the evil regime is vanquished. That is what happened when the United States fought and won a hot war against Germany and Japan and a cold war against the Soviet Union.


The greatest obstacle to peace in our time, or in any time, has been people who misdiagnose evil people and evil regimes. Such people believe that evil can be appeased. In fact, evil must be vanquished in and by every generation. The only way to accomplish that objective is to deliberately and forcefully oppose evil.


We need an award for the well intentioned but self-deceived. Let's call it the Ignominious Appeasement Award. Unlike the Nobel Peace Prize, this award will be easy to define. To appease means"to buy off an aggressor by concessions, usually at the sacrifice of principles." Ignominious means"dishonorable; deserving of shame or infamy; despicable."


Does this not describe what happened in America's dealings with North Korea? In the Clinton administration's 1994 agreement with Pyongyang (the one sealed by then-Secretary of State Madeleine Albright who danced a celebratory jig in front of North Korean security guards), North Korea promised to freeze nuclear weapons development in exchange for two light-water reactors to be financed mostly by Japan and South Korea.

The United States further promised to provide free fuel oil to help meet North Korea's energy needs. Work was well underway on the reactors when Pyongyang admitted last week it was not living up to its end of the deal and, in fact, had been moving ahead all along toward building a nuclear bomb.


In other words (surprise!) Communist dictators lie. Jimmy Carter helped broker this deal. It was Carter who expressed surprise that the late Soviet dictator Leonid Brezhnev lied to him after Brezhnev ordered Soviet troops to invade and occupy Afghanistan in December, 1979. Undeterred by a lying Soviet dictator, Carter pressed on to work his magic with North Korea and saw his (and America's) pocket picked again.


The fault in this equation is that good people think they can make bad people good if the good people give the bad people something, mostly economic aid and a teaspoon of"understanding" to flavor the corrupted brew. A hall of infamy could be filled with political, diplomatic, religious, academic and intellectual leaders who have put their faith in appeasement to forestall war, often seeing a worse war come about as a result of their naivete.


The Nobel Prize includes a $1 million award for the recipient. The Ignominious Peace Prize would be accompanied by cash, too. It wouldn't be a cash award - it would be a fine. The recipient would be penalized for being so ignorant of the history of appeasement that he would risk the lives and freedom of others in a futile and counterproductive quest for"peace." The fine would go to the families of people wrongly imprisoned or executed by these regimes as partial propitiation for the naivete of do-gooders who ought to have known better.


Jimmy Carter would be the first recipient of the Ignominious Peace Prize. Let's fine him $1 million so he can break even, which is more than the world is going to do because some stupidly trusted North Korea to abide by a treaty.

Direct all mail for Cal Thomas to: Tribune Media Services, 435 N. Michigan Ave, Suite 1500, Chicago, Ill. 60611. Readers may also leave e-mail at






The Ignominious Appeasement Award