Southern Baptist leader Russell Moore — an outspoken critic of President Trump — and another top-ranking denominational leader discussed strengthening ties across the Protestant network of churches in meeting that occurred amid buzz that Moore’s job was at risk.
A joint statement issued Monday (March 13) evening by Moore, who leads the Southern Baptist Convention’s public policy arm, and Frank Page, the president of the denomination’s Executive Committee, said that afternoon’s two-hour meeting deepened their friendship and understanding on how to move the denomination forward.
“We fully support one another and look forward to working together on behalf of Southern Baptists in the years to come. We will collaborate on developing future steps to deepen connections with all Southern Baptists as we work together to advance the great commission of our lord Jesus Christ,” the statement read.
The pair “met as colleagues committed to the same priorities of proclaiming the gospel” to everyone, the statement said. They also talked about addressing biblical and gospel issues, including religious liberty, racial reconciliation and the sanctity of human life.
News of the expected meeting between the two men was first reported Monday morning by the Washington Post. The newspaper reported that Page said he hoped for reconciliation between Moore and those who oppose him, but had not ruled out asking for Moore’s resignation if the meeting did not go well. Moore’s employment status is not up to Page.
In the aftermath of Trump’s victory, backlash from prominent Southern Baptist leaders raised questions about whether Moore’s job was at risk. Moore, the face of the Nashville-based denomination, became a consistent critic of Trump and his supporters during the divisive 2016 election cycle.
Monday’s meeting did not focus on Moore’s resignation nor the future of his job as the president of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, Roger “Sing” Oldham, the spokesman for the Executive Committee, said in an email. The commission has offices in Nashville and Washington, D.C.
“The goal of the meeting from the get-go was to find bridge-building strategies to effect reconciliation and build unity within the Southern Baptist network of churches,” Oldham said. “The Executive Committee has no authority over any of the (Southern Baptist Convention) entity leaders; oversight of each (Southern Baptist Convention) entity president rests with the respective board of trustees.”
Moore told RNS in an interview in late January that he was confident he would be able to remain in his post.
“Oh yes I’m committed to the long haul and very encouraged in what the Lord’s doing these days,” he said at the time. “The people who have concerns, I totally understand that and these are great guys. And so I have nothing negative to say about them at all.”
Several Southern Baptist churches across the country have pulled or threatened to withhold their contributions to the denomination’s Cooperative Program, the Southern Baptist Convention’s funding mechanism for state and national initiatives. Recently, the Executive Committee decided to study how many churches are escrowing their gifts to the fund and why they’re doing it, Oldham said.
Last month Pastor Jack Graham, a former president of the Southern Baptist Convention, told the Baptist Message in Louisiana that his Texas church was escrowing $1 million in Cooperative Program funds out of concerns for the direction of the denomination. In a December Wall Street Journal article, Graham said Moore’s remarks came with a “disrespectfulness” toward other evangelicals.
During the 2016 election season, Moore called out Trump’s moral fitness and questioned his conservative Christian supporters in a number of editorials and interviews, and even sparred with Trump on Twitter. Moore took on parts of Trump’s platform, including immigration policies and his campaign rhetoric against Muslims.
In late December, Moore addressed the denominational division in his “Election Year Thoughts at Christmastime” blog post, and apologized to anyone who thought his critiques of Trump meant he was criticizing anyone who voted for Trump.
Last week Byron Day, the president of the National African American Fellowship of the Southern Baptist Convention, called for reconciliation in a March 9 open letter to Southern Baptists, the Baptist Press reported.
Internal denominational tussles are not uncommon in the Southern Baptist Convention, which calls itself the largest Protestant denomination in the U.S. with more than 15 million members.
Barry Hankins, a history professor at Baylor University, sees the crux of this recent tension as two views on how Southern Baptists should engage politically coming to a head. Hankins, who co-authored “Baptists in America: A History,” said it speaks in part to a generational divide among Southern Baptists.
One camp, typically older members, thinks tightly aligning with the Republican Party will help them achieve two key issue goals — stopping abortion and upholding opposite-sex marriages — and calling out the GOP for other issues jeopardizes that mission, Hankins said.
The other camp, the one Moore falls under, also is theologically conservative, but does not think Southern Baptists should be so closely aligned with one party and that criticizing the GOP is appropriate at times, Hankins said. This group views a wide array of issues as important.
From Hankins’ perspective as a believer and historian, he thinks if Moore has to leave because of this tension it signals that the convention is too closely connected with the Republican Party, and that’s a “bad thing.”
“If he can’t speak biblically on issues when his position doesn’t line up with the Republican Party, what does that say about the status of the Southern Baptist Convention?” Hankins said. “It just doesn’t speak very well for an organization that’s supposed to be theologically and biblically grounded as opposed to being involved in partisan politics with one party or another.”
A version of this story originally appeared in USA Today. Adelle M. Banks contributed to this report.
Photo: Russell Moore preaching at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary on Oct. 9, 2011.
Photo courtesy: Wikimedia Commons
Publication date: March 14, 2017